a couple of hot dogs sitting on top of a wooden table
Photo by Kateryna Hliznitsova on Unsplash
6 min read

Discovering Athens, Ohio: A Gastronomic Adventure

Nestled in the rolling hills of southeastern Ohio, Athens is a charming city known for its vibrant arts scene, historic architecture, and, perhaps most importantly, its diverse and delightful culinary landscape. Whether you're a food connoisseur or just a hungry traveler, Athens offers an abundance of dining options to satisfy every craving. From cozy cafes to upscale dining experiences, Athens' food scene is a reflection of its unique cultural tapestry. Let's embark on a flavorful journey to some of the best food stops that the city has to offer.

1. Casa Nueva - A Taste of Locally Sourced Goodness

One of the most beloved eateries in Athens, Casa Nueva is more than just a restaurant; it’s a community-run institution founded on the principles of sustainable sourcing and community development. Known for its inventive take on traditional Mexican dishes, every ingredient at Casa Nueva is thoughtfully chosen to ensure quality and freshness.

Here, you can savor dishes such as carnitas burritos and chorizo quesadillas, all made from locally sourced ingredients. Their vegetarian and vegan options ensure that every guest leaves satisfied, making it a must-visit for eco-conscious travelers.

Traveler's Tip: Pair your meal with a locally brewed beer or a margarita to complete the experience. Getting there before peak hours is advisable as this hotspot can get quite busy, especially on weekends.

2. Brennan's Coffee Cafe - Morning Delight

For travelers who believe in starting their day with a perfect cup of coffee, Brennan's Coffee Cafe is undoubtedly the place to be. Located in the heart of Athens, this cafe is a welcoming spot with comfortable seating, perfect for enjoying some downtime or catching up on emails.

Brennan's offers a delightful array of breakfast options, including freshly baked pastries and hearty breakfast sandwiches that melt in your mouth. The coffee, of course, is the star of the show, brewed to perfection with a wide selection of beans to choose from.

Traveler's Tip: Don’t miss a chance to taste their homemade seasonal muffins; they are an absolute treat!

3. O'Betty's Red Hot - The Funky Hot Dog Joint

For a truly unique dining experience, head to O'Betty's Red Hot. This quirky and eclectic spot is famous for its loaded hot dogs served with a variety of creative toppings. Each hot dog is named after a famous burlesque dancer, adding a touch of whimsy and personality to the menu.

From "Varla" with sauerkraut and onions to the "Tempest" topped with chili and cheese, there’s something for every hot dog lover at O'Betty's. The vibrant decor full of retro memorabilia complements the playful menu perfectly.

Traveler's Tip: Try their hand-cut fries and homemade sauces for a full, satisfying meal.

4. Court Street Diner - A Nostalgic Trip to the 50s

If you're yearning for a blast from the past, stop by the Court Street Diner. This retro-style diner offers a nostalgic experience reminiscent of the 1950s. From its checkered floor and vinyl booths to the jukebox in the corner, every aspect transports you back to a simpler time.

The menu includes all the classic American diner staples. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty breakfast platter or a juicy cheeseburger with a side of crispy fries, Court Street Diner will not disappoint.

Traveler's Tip: Their milkshakes are legendary, thick, and creamy, making them the perfect sweet treat to accompany your meal.

5. The Athens Farmers Market - Fresh and Organic Finds

Athens Farmers Market is not your typical food stop, but it’s a culinary adventure and a chance to engage with the community. Open year-round on Saturdays, this market is a haven for foodies who love to explore fresh, local produce, artisanal breads, and hand-crafted cheeses.

From seasonal fruits and vegetables to local honey and baked goods, the market is a celebration of regional flavors. It provides an excellent opportunity to gather ingredients for a picnic or to bring a taste of Athens back home.

Traveler's Tip: Arrive early to get the best picks and enjoy live music for a fuller weekend experience.

6. Zoe Fine Dining - Athens’ Elegant Eatery

For those who want to indulge in an upscale dining experience, Zoe Fine Dining is the premier destination. This elegantly appointed restaurant offers a sophisticated menu that emphasizes seasonal ingredients and creative pairings.

Whether you choose the expertly cooked rack of lamb or the fresh seafood specials, each dish at Zoe is a masterpiece. The presentation, flavor, and service combine to create an unforgettable dining experience.

Traveler's Tip: Consider making reservations, especially on weekends or during university events, to secure your table in this popular fine dining spot.

7. Bagel Street Deli - More Than Just Bagels

Often hailed as one of the best spots for a quick bite in Athens, Bagel Street Deli is loved by students and locals alike. This unique bagel shop offers an impressive selection of sandwiches crafted with delicious bagels. The menu is full of inventive combinations, from classic BLTs to creative takes like the "Tom Turkey."

Beyond bagels, the deli offers an inviting, laid-back atmosphere that embodies the spirit of Athens itself, making it perfect for a casual lunch or a quick snack before exploring more of the city.

Traveler's Tip: Not sure what to order? Try the "Gandalf" with avocado, cucumber, and green pepper—it's a perennial favorite.

8. Avalanche Pizza - Slices with a Difference

Pizza lovers rejoice! Avalanche Pizza is your go-to spot for a slice of heaven in Athens. Known for its high-quality ingredients and creative pizza offerings, this local pizzeria serves slices and whole pies that are both inventive and delicious.

Every pizza is stone-baked to perfection, with dough made fresh daily. Whether you're in the mood for the classic margherita or an exotic option like the "Pizza Aloha" with pineapple and jalapeños, there's a flavor for every preference.

Traveler's Tip: Don’t forget to check out their selection of local craft beers, which pair wonderfully with their pizza offerings.

9. Latitude 39 - A Fusion of Global Flavors

Located within the Ohio University campus, Latitude 39 is perfect for those curious about global cuisine. This trendy eatery offers a fusion of flavors from around the world, providing a diverse menu selection that is both exciting and delicious.

The restaurant prides itself on its contemporary dishes, such as Korean BBQ tacos and chicken tikka flatbreads, each thoughtfully prepared to excite your taste buds. It's the ideal spot for diners looking for something a bit out of the ordinary.

Traveler's Tip: Check out their nightly specials, a great way to try something new without breaking the bank.

10. The Pigskin Bar and Grille - Athens' Liveliest Hangout

No food journey in Athens is complete without a visit to The Pigskin Bar and Grille. It’s a favorite among locals, students, and visitors, known for its vibrant atmosphere and hearty comfort food.

The culinary offerings include monster burgers, succulent steaks, and their legendary wings, all of which are perfect for satisfying hunger after a day of exploring the city. With its lively ambiance, it’s also a great spot to catch a game or enjoy some live music.

Traveler's Tip: Time your visit to coincide with the happy hour deals for a great blend of dining and entertainment without straining your budget.

Conclusion

Athens, Ohio, is more than just a college town; it's a culinary hotspot that proudly showcases the diversity and creativity of its people. From casual eateries to fine dining establishments, the city's food scene offers a wide array of flavors and experiences that are sure to please any palate. As you savor each bite, you're also savoring the richness of Athens' culture.

While you're in Athens, don't forget to explore its hidden treasures and consider spending some time in neighborhoods filled with character and charm. To make your visit truly memorable, ensure you take advantage of the experiences that the city is totally worth the hype—all while indulging in its exceptional culinary offerings. Happy eating!

Discover Athens

Read more in our Athens 2024 Travel Guide.

Athens Travel Guide